Doesn't Brown Sugar Pudding sound delicious? I thought so, too, and decided to make it to bring to a dinner party Saturday night.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhX8sEXlnqv0VXYLTUBaXlRJtTObZn3oAhveUKIPQzEArtaEQ0qCeGvGs-IAlka-NJEeUfH5i-67b5-rleYFUDF0Pmv9r5xi-6ptlTpAZKwY1nNk8krLIhS2tKYv5fIy61ulOfQwuDURg/s640/brown+sugar+boiling.jpg) |
Boiling up the brown sugar, water and butter. |
The recipe was quite unusual, which added to the intrigue. I had never encountered this technique: boil up some brown sugar, butter and water, and then add dollops of cake batter atop the liquid and bake in the oven.
As I prepared this oddity, I had the sinking feeling it wouldn't work. But you know when you're positive you failed a test, and then engage in magical thinking, i.e., praying that some miracle occurred and you passed with flying colors? That's what happened to me. Although the further I got into the recipe, and less confident I became, once it was in the oven, magical thinking took over. I was hoping for some radical, pastry world rocket science physics-defying transformation in my oven.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgrRBfohRgvRtnunoK2mQE-Vd7YKYPIlA7FblzewQV67sQCHTEeJkTYbDmt_kftj2ZvhChjJ9sFAJhjrEoR9VL4sqcaI5YkNuR184-Peou9HrElkggcwcIsXyOFfIEMivNyBvqt2z2-1Q/s640/cake+batter.jpg) |
The cake batter looked normal enough. |
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEg2-wDsOWvSlQmWqjmoL6pWfZy-X1aUu9Qq58WeEHBSval5ntL_lj8BPH_IUlJgRA6tq7dWZYjDmQVXUcu-kAgOlgSMVyCNxtcDNxujtYT_Vg-Qrm-JMblEXmSsWSG7NmQamIvYJeT4vQ/s640/ready+for+the+oven+%2528and+the+garbage%2521%2529.jpg) |
Ready for the oven. |
But it what emerged from the oven was not some smooth and delicious Brown Sugar Pudding. It was Cake Soup. A crunchy cake layer floating on a soup of liquid brown sugar. Although it actually tasted pretty good, there was no way I was going to take this soupy mess on the subway to a swanky dinner party in Chelsea.
This recipe card is from a filled-to-the brim recipe box that DH bought on ETSY and gave to me for Christmas. It was full of promise, and nearly 150 recipes. But now I'm a bit suspect, for the first recipe I made from the box also failed. Sweet Chocolate Cupcakes did taste good, but the batter cemented itself to the paper liners, making it impossible to eat the cakes without ingesting a bit of paper too. That's the kind of fiber you don't want.
My sister-in-law Margaret (and A Cake Bakes enthusiast) who was visiting and witnessed these two disasters, put forth this theory: As soon as the owner of this recipe box died, her family all said: Quick, let's get rid of Granny's recipes, she was such a horrible baker.
The failed Sweet Chocolate Cupcakes, above.