Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Eleanor's Amazing Date (Cake)

At the beginning of the 20th century, and right through the 1950s, date cakes were commonplace.  They were served at church dinners and picnics, at afternoon tea and Sunday supper.  Nearly all of my recipe boxes and cookbooks feature at least one, and often several, date cake recipes.

I don't know why date cakes fell out of favor; dates add moisture and a unique complex sweetness to baked goods.  (Plus, they are a truly sensuous fruit, unlike raisins which I associate with disappointing childhood snacks and dried up pellets whose only use was to turn their cardboard box containers into rattles.)  I bought the box of dates (above) and they were so addicting that I had to put them in a cake before I ate every last one.

Try to get "real" buttermilk, instead of the commercial product sold in most supermarkets.

This takes a *bit* of work to put together, but your efforts will be rewarded with a stunning, scrumptious cake.  The steps are many:  grate the orange peel, chop the nuts and dates and flour them, separate the eggs and whip the whites, alternate adding the dry ingredients with the buttermilk -- you get the picture.  The dates I used were so moist that even after being chopped and floured  they clung together in clumps, as if they were on teenagers on a date.

Using good eggs (not the cheap supermarket variety) makes for a better cake.

Grating orange rind is easy if you use a microplane.

To avoid overbeating the egg whites, add a bit of cream of tartar to them shortly after you start whipping them. Fold carefully into the batter, so as not to deflate them.

This recipe calls for a topping to be spooned over the cake while it's still in the pan.  Don't cook the ingredients (as I did until I realized my mistake).  Just mix them together and spoon atop the warm cake while it's still in the pan. I was worried that the sugar in the topping would cement the cake to the pan, but it released beautifully.  It was a sweet, comforting, real taste of the past.


  1. i feel the same way about raisins! my mother regularly made date-nut bread and i love my m-i-l's date bar recipe. me, i love a date wrapped in bacon.

  2. A woman after my own heart! The first time I ever had a date was in elementary school, and the teacher brought some in for us to try. Just to be sure we would like them, she coated them with confectioners' sugar!!

  3. I love me some dates. This is a definite must-try.

  4. Sophie: You won't be sorry! It is so delicious. Thanks for your comment.

  5. Hi Susan, looks delicious! I totally agree with you on the dates -- they really are underrated. Thanks for helping them make a comeback :)

  6. @Kathryn: Thanks for the encouragement for my "date" mission!

  7. I tried a lot of modern recipes but was not what I wanted! Your old cookbook is that what I was looking for!

  8. Hi Susan,

    Recipe looks delicious, but I need help deciphering the third cake ingredient. Is that 1 cup oil or 1 cup butter?

  9. Bixy: Sorry about that -- I should type all these up. It says two sticks of oleo (a brand of margarine no longer made). I suggest using two sticks of butter (one cup) for superior flavor. Let me know how it turns out!